I stood at Chris’s parents’ front door, clutching his arm. “We want them at our wedding, right?” I asked, trying to sound optimistic.
Chris let out a breath. “If they can’t accept you, I don’t care anymore.”
But I didn’t buy that. We both needed closure.
Inside, Mrs. Castillo greeted me with her usual cold smile. No matter how many times I tried to win them over, I was always the outsider—the woman who had taken their son away from Ciara, the polished daughter of their well-connected friends.
Chris and I had met by chance—a minor car accident outside my office. We fell in love fast. But the first time I met his parents, I knew they’d never approve.
“She’s an assistant?” I overheard his mother whisper. “Ciara adores you.”
But Chris defended me. That’s the man I said yes to. That’s the man I was secretly carrying a child for.
Yes, I was pregnant. Chris didn’t know yet. I was planning to surprise him.
Maybe, just maybe, this baby would be the thing that finally brought us all together.
At dinner, I gathered my courage. “We have news,” I said. “I’m pregnant.”
Silence.
Then Mrs. Castillo muttered, “He’s infertile.”
I blinked, confused. “What? That’s not true—we’ve been trying.”
Chris didn’t speak. He just stared at his plate. And then the chaos broke loose—his mother yelling, accusing me of trapping him, even grabbing my hair while I begged Chris to say something. Anything. He didn’t.
Days later, I came home to an empty apartment. On the counter: medical papers and a sticky note.
“I’m infertile. I hope you have a good life, but it won’t be with me.”
He believed I’d cheated. But I hadn’t. That baby was his. I tried calling. No answer. I showed up—his parents called the police.
“Fine,” I said, heartbroken. “I’ll raise this baby on my own.”
And I did. I named him Paul. He looked just like his father. Every day, his blue eyes reminded me of Chris, but I kept going—for my son.
Then one day, I ran into Chris on the street.
“Amanda?” he said, stunned, eyes dropping to the photo on my phone—Paul’s face.
“You don’t get to look at him,” I snapped, walking away.
A week later, I heard he was engaged to Ciara. Just like his parents always wanted.
But then something unexpected happened.
At a family dinner, Ciara’s mother joked about future grandchildren. Chris reminded her, “I’m infertile.”
She laughed. “That was part of the plan.”
The plan.
That’s when it all came crashing down. His infertility? A lie. Cooked up by his parents and Ciara’s family. Even the clinic results were fake.
Chris left immediately and came to my apartment. I found him asleep on my bed, tear-streaked, broken.
“You’ve got five seconds before I call the cops,” I warned.
“Amanda, please—hear me out.”
So I did.
The truth unraveled. The false diagnosis, the betrayal, the manipulation. Everything finally made sense—my pregnancy, his silence, his disappearance.
“I should’ve trusted you,” he said.
“Yes,” I answered. “You should’ve.”
He asked to be part of Paul’s life. I wasn’t sure. It had been so hard, raising him alone. This wasn’t how things were supposed to go.
“I don’t know if we can go back,” I said quietly.
“I’ll earn it,” he promised. “You and Paul—you’re my real family.”
I looked into his eyes and saw it—remorse, honesty, determination.
“First,” I said, “you should meet your son.”
Then, almost involuntarily, I smiled. “And we’re probably going to have to sue Mr. Geoffrey.”
Chris let out a wet laugh.
And for the first time in a long while, it felt like maybe something good could come out of all this hurt.